In family law, few developments have transformed financial remedy practice as quickly as the rise of the Private Financial Dispute Resolution hearing, more commonly known as the Private FDR or pFDR. Once considered a niche option primarily utilised by high-net-worth individuals, pFDRs are now becoming an increasingly mainstream method of resolving financial disputes following the end of a marriage.
What is a financial dispute resolution?
A Financial Dispute Resolution hearing (FDR) is a settlement-focused hearing where an experienced judge, or in the case of a private FDR, an agreed private evaluator, provides an indication of the likely outcome should the matter proceed to a final hearing. This judicial steer often assists parties in bridging the gap between their respective positions and reaching a negotiated settlement. Avoiding the costly and risky final hearing can be seen as a large benefit to parties when they are looking at their future finances and how they progress after divorce.
What’s the difference between an FDR and a private FDR?
The key difference between an FDR and a pFDR is that a pFDR takes place outside the court system. The parties jointly instruct a respected barrister, King’s Counsel, retired judge or senior family law solicitor to act as the evaluator. Unlike the court process, where hearings may be delayed, adjourned or listed many months in advance, a pFDR can usually be arranged within weeks and at a date convenient to everyone involved. Therefore, avoiding the added stress of a court hearing being listed on a date that requires a large amount of rescheduling, whether that is work, arrangements for the children or a plan that has been made months in advance.
Why are pFDRs becoming more popular?
The growing popularity of pFDRs has been driven by a combination of factors.
Firstly, court delays continue to be a challenge across the family justice system. Whilst significant work has been undertaken to improve efficiency, lengthy waiting times remain between hearings, particularly in busy Financial Remedies Courts. Against that backdrop, parties are increasingly seeking alternatives that allow them to progress matters expeditiously.
Secondly, a private FDR offers significantly more time and attention than a traditional court FDR. In court, judges are often responsible for multiple cases on the same day and even at the same time, meaning that the judge is not always readily available at the time the hearing is listed. By contrast, the private FDR evaluator is dedicated solely to one case, your case, having reviewed the papers in advance and remaining available throughout the day to assist with negotiations. This often results in more detailed feedback and a greater opportunity for meaningful settlement discussions.
There is also the benefit of choice. Parties can select an evaluator with particular expertise in the issues involved, whether that be complex business interests, pensions, inherited wealth or international elements.
The benefits of a Private FDR
The advantages are substantial:
- Earlier resolution and reduced delay.
- Greater flexibility in fixing hearing dates.
- Choice of evaluator with relevant expertise.
- Dedicated time devoted exclusively to the case.
- Potentially enhanced settlement prospects (subject to the parties positions).
- Potential cost savings, as settling at an earlier stage can avoid the significant legal costs associated with preparation for a final hearing.
Whilst there is an additional upfront cost in paying the private evaluator and potentially venue expenses, that cost can often be outweighed by the savings achieved through avoiding further contested litigation.
The wider shift towards Non-Court Dispute Resolution
The increase in pFDRs also reflects a broader movement within family law towards Non-Court Dispute Resolution (NCDR). Changes to the Family Procedure Rules have strengthened the court’s expectation that parties actively consider alternative methods of resolving disputes before asking the court to determine matters for them. These methods include mediation, arbitration, early neutral evaluation and, increasingly, private FDRs.
The recent development in the news
The growth of alternative dispute resolution in family law has received significant attention in recent years. Readers interested in developments in this area may wish to explore:
- The judiciary’s continuing emphasis on Non-Court Dispute Resolution through updates from the Family Justice Council and the Family Procedure Rule Committee.
- Coverage by Resolution, a national organisation for family justice professionals, regarding changes to the Family Procedure Rules and increasing encouragement for parties to engage in NCDR before contested proceedings.
- Commentary from leading family law chambers including 1 King’s Bench Walk, and Queen Elizabeth Building Chambers who have reported a marked increase in demand for private FDRs in recent years.
Looking ahead
Private FDRs are no longer viewed as a luxury reserved for the very wealthy. They have become an established and highly effective mechanism for resolving financial disputes following the end of a marriage. As courts continue to encourage parties to explore alternatives to litigation and as clients seek greater control over both costs and outcomes, it appears likely that pFDRs will remain one of the most influential developments in family law practice for years to come.
For many separating couples, the question is no longer whether a pFDR is available, but whether they can afford not to consider one.
Get In Touch
David Miles is a Solicitor in the Family team and is based at our Manchester office. Our family law team is able to provide advice on a wide variety of family law including those arising from the end of a marriage.
Should you have any questions please do not hesitate to contact us on 0330 111 3131 or fill in our contact form and we’ll be in touch.
This article is for information only and does not constitute legal advice. We recommend seeking professional advice before taking any action on the information provided. If you would like to discuss your specific circumstances, please feel free to contact us on 0330 111 3131.
